Headline RoundupMay 23rd, 2024
Supreme Court, January 6, Capitol Chaos, Samuel Alito, Politics
Summary from the AllSides News Team
Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito is facing controversy over two flags flown at his personal residence. What do the flags represent, and was it wrong for a justice to display them?
What Do the Flags Represent? The Washington Examiner (Lean Right bias) determined the upside-down American flag originally served to indicate distress or danger and was later used as a symbol of protest, primarily used by “liberal, pacifist, environmentalist, and minority activists.” In 2020, “Trump supporters began adopting the flag, primarily at ‘Stop the Steal’ rallies alleging election fraud.” The “Appeal to Heaven” flag was a primary flag flown during the Revolutionary War that later became “popular among Christians and Republicans.” The article concluded this flag was “flown by several of those present at the Jan. 6 riot, but it doesn’t appear to have played an outsize role.”
Why Did Alito Fly Them? A writer in MSNBC (Left bias) argued Alito’s response to the controversy is “befitting for a public servant who clearly believes he has no responsibility to the public.” The writer determined that “Alito surely knows now the significance of the upside-down flag and its symbolic importance to Trump and his supporters.” Given this, the writer asked, “So here’s the question for Alito: why not apologize? Even if Alito believes he did nothing wrong, why not simply say he’s sorry if people drew the wrong impression from the upside-down flag? The answer is not difficult to discern: He does not care.”
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
Samuel Alito’s child-like petulance would almost be amusing — except for one thing
MSNBC See rating detailsOpinion
On Thursday, The New York Times reported that 11 days after the Jan. 6 insurrection and three days before Joe Biden’s inauguration, an upside-down flag was seen flying outside Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito’s home. This act is usually a symbol of distress, but after the 2020 election it became a form of political protest for many Trump supporters to signal their belief that the vote had been stolen from the soon-to-be former president.
Alito’s explanation for the upside-down flag on his property has been, how shall we say, creative....
From the Center
Democrats renew calls for US Supreme Court's Alito to recuse amid flag flap
Reuters See rating details
Erin Schaff/Pool via REUTERS/File Photo
News
Democrats intensified their calls on Thursday for U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito to step aside in two cases - one on Donald Trump's bid for immunity from prosecution and the other on a charge involving the Capitol attack - after a media report that another provocative flag flew outside one of his homes.
A flag bearing the phrase "Appeal to Heaven" flew outside Alito's vacation home on Long Beach Island, New Jersey, in July and September of 2023, the New York Times reported on Wednesday, citing photographs and interviews....
From the Right
What are the flags Alito is under fire for?
Washington Examiner See rating details
AP Photo/Ted Powers
Analysis
Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito has come under intense pressure from Democrats for the flying of two flags at his residences.
He first came under fire after an upside-down American flag was spotted at his home in Virginia. Days later, reports about him flying an “An Appeal to Heaven” flag over his vacation home reignited calls for his recusal from various Jan. 6-related cases before the court. Critics claimed the flags are symbols of the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol riot and far-right extremists.
Here is everything to know about the...
Possible Paywall
More headline roundups
AllSides Picks
Jim Lo Scalzo/Pool/Sipa USA
HEADLINE ROUNDUP
Supreme Court Rules in Favor of NRA, Allowing First Amendment Case to Proceed
May 30th, 2024
Dave Sanders, The New York Times via Associated Press, Pool
HEADLINE ROUNDUP
Jury Finds Trump Guilty on All 34 Charges in Hush Money Case
May 30th, 2024
REUTERS/Hatem Khaled
Story of the Week
Israel Tests Biden's 'Red Line' With Rafah Airstrike
AllSides Staff
May 30th, 2024
Tidewater Muse/ Flickr
Recommended Reading
AllSides Staff
May 29th, 2024
News and Information about Supreme Court
More News about Supreme Court from the Left, Center and Right
From the Left
From the Center
From the Right
News
Chief Justice John Roberts declines to meet with Democratic lawmakers about ethics flap and Alito’s flags CNN DigitalNews
Alito Refuses Calls for Recusal Over Display of Provocative Flags New York Times (News)News
The Untold Story of the Network That Took Down Roe v. Wade New York Times (News)Analysis
In a pre-Dobbs world, the Washington Post deferred to a Supreme Court justice SemaforNews
Samuel Alito’s wife claimed upside-down flag was ‘international sign of distress’ The GuardianFact Check
Was it legal to fly the flag upside down at Samuel Alito’s house? PolitiFactNews
Supreme Court finds no bias against Black voters in a South Carolina congressional district Associated PressNews
Clarence Thomas attacks Brown v. Education ruling amid 70th anniversary AxiosAnalysis
The Supreme Court decides not to trigger a second Great Depression VoxNews
Justice Alito warns of declining support for freedom of speech on college campuses NBC News DigitalNews
Supreme Court Rejects Musk’s ‘Twitter Sitter’ Appeal in SEC Win BloombergNews
Supreme Court waves off Kari Lake lawsuit over electronic voting CNN DigitalNews
Supreme Court agrees to hear Biden admin appeal in ghost guns case AxiosNews
Lawmakers seek disavowal of Supreme Court's racist 'Insular Cases' that limited rights of people in U.S. territories NBC News DigitalNews
Clarence Thomas returns after unexplained absence as Supreme Court hears Jan. 6 case USA TODAYNews
Biden predicts next president will appoint ‘a couple justices’ The HillNews
Bump stock ruling could trigger booming rapid-fire marketplace The HillNews
US Supreme Court allows Louisiana voting map with two Black-majority districts ReutersNews
Supreme Court appears likely to side with Trump on some presidential immunity SCOTUSblogNews
Jan. 6 defendant asks Supreme Court to throw out obstruction charge SCOTUSblogNews
Supreme Court Refuses to Take Amy Coney Barrett's Case NewsweekNews
Fears grow over Comstock Act, Justices Thomas, Alito The HillNews
Texas immigration law SB4 returns to court in legal whiplash NewsNationNews
Supreme Court Justice Warns Greg Abbott Will 'Sow Chaos' at Border NewsweekNews
Alito extends pause on Texas law allowing state arrests of migrants NewsNationNews
Maine secretary of state withdraws Trump ballot ban The HillNews
U.S. Supreme Court to decide Louisiana congressional redistricting case The Times-PicayuneNews
State seeks to salvage high-profile conviction in Hadiya Pendleton slaying in arguments before Illinois Supreme Court Chicago TribuneNews
Supreme Court justices slammed by judge: "Incredibly dishonest" NewsweekNews
Supreme Court clears the way for the NRA’s free speech lawsuit against an ex-New York official New York Post (News)News
Justice Alito refuses call to recuse, says flags were flown by his wife Washington TimesNews
Washington Post reveals it passed on Alito flag story in 2021 after confrontation with justice's wife Fox News DigitalNews
Justices Thomas and Alito — typically in agreement — split in major CFPB ruling Washington TimesNews
Decision time for Supreme Court on big, hot-button questions; justices hear final oral arguments Washington TimesNews
GOP state lawmakers appeal to SCOTUS to challenge Biden's 'usurpations' of their power to run elections Fox News DigitalNews
Trump attorney, Supreme Court justice clash on whether a president who 'ordered' a 'coup' could be prosecuted Fox News DigitalNews
Trump v US: SCOTUS likely to determine presidents get ‘some amount’ of immunity, experts say Fox News DigitalOpinion
The Supreme Court Should Rule Swiftly on Trump’s Immunity Claim Liz CheneyNews
Supreme Court won’t hear Kari Lake case to ban electronic vote tabulators in Arizona elections Washington TimesNews
Supreme Court struggles with how to police homeless encampments Washington TimesNews
Kari Lake tries to thread the needle on abortion after Arizona Supreme Court ruling Washington ExaminerNews
Democratic senator makes shocking statement about Obama-appointed Justice Sotomayor Washington ExaminerOpinion
Texas, the Border and the Supreme Court Wall Street Journal (Opinion)News
The Supreme Court Hands the Campus Surveillance State a Lifeline National Review (News)